Evaluating local funding: seeing value
Rob Fellman is one of the lead authors of the Make/Shift 2025/2026 evaluation and part of the RMR team who have worked with several Creative People and Places projects.
In this post, drawing on Make/Shift’s work, he explores what happens when programme funding is moved around between projects, rather than controlled as a traditional ‘fixed’ budget line which is handed out ‘from above’. By looking at these flows (rather than only counting what is easiest to measure) Rob invites readers to consider how funds and resources travel, who they touch, and what kinds of future activity, skills, and collaborations they can support and nourish.
How it came about
I was lucky enough to work as an evaluator alongside Make/Shift - feeding into the approach and evaluation which my colleague Ruth has previously written about: working with Make/Shift and using Stories of Change.
Reflecting on their first 3-year phase while writing the final evaluation report, I became really interested in the question:
What happens when funding is handed out with trust, to move closer to the people and places it is meant to serve?
This led to a case study on their work titled ‘Flows’.
The results point to something important: when people have the freedom to use funding in ways that make sense for their communities, the benefits can extend far beyond the original pounds and pence.
Money doesn’t simply get ‘spent’: it circulates, connects, and can create wider social and economic value along the way.
This is where evaluation becomes especially useful: if we only measure what is easy to count, we risk missing the real story… (see the ‘McNamara Fallacy’ - this understanding goes way back, but is even more relevant today in a data-driven society)
Why this kind of evaluation matters
Important outcomes of community funding are not immediate or easy to measure, so we looked at an approach that gives a more complete picture of value.
Make/Shift are a pioneering organisation in so many ways, and it was a real pleasure to work with them.
They are always keen to view the boundaries of ‘traditional’ systems not as obstacles, but—as my colleague Ruth calls them—‘challenges to climb over’ which we as evaluators try to apply to our own practice too, as we navigate our own function and purpose.
Chatting with Creative Director Rachel Smith, we realised we were both keen to use this opportunity to think differently, to show Make/Shift’s approach to direct-to-community funding in a different light, beyond traditional ‘return-on-investment’ style metrics.
After all, it made sense to find a way of evaluating Make/Shift’s work that was closer to their own style of ecosystem thinking. In short: how these different systems and processes interact to make a well-balanced and self-sustaining whole.
“Evaluation […] has to develop ways of reflecting the work it is a part of”
Considering the ebbs and flows of finances (and decision-making points) within a system seemed a fitting choice. I chose to map the journey of Make/Shift’s funding, as it wove its way through the local communities and decision-makers, to stimulate grassroots creative activity.
The resulting flow-based evaluation asked different questions; we wanted to see where money goes, how it moves, and what kinds of relationships, skills, and local activity it helps to generate.
That matters because often the most important outcomes of community funding are not immediate, or easy to measure; they (hopefully) show up later as stronger networks, new collaborations, more local spending, or greater confidence among participants.
I believe that this kind of evaluation gives a more complete picture of value, or at least shows the possibilities for this type of analysis (which I personally hope to do more of).
Figure 1: Flows of money from income sources to expenditure across 2024-2026, through national/regional/local lens for Make/Shift CPP
Seeing money as something that moves
Rather than treating funding as a one-off transaction, this type of study shows money passing through a network of partners, collaborators, and community groups operating and spending their money within the local economy, before eventually passing to local community activity, and then into the local economy itself.
This is a much more useful way of thinking about local investment, because the impact of money is rarely limited to the first person or organisation that receives it.
“not how money was used, so much as what it sets in motion”
A fee paid to a community member might later be spent with a local shop, a venue, a freelancer, or a small business. In that way, one funding payment can support several layers of local activity.
Why local spending matters
Money often recirculates when it stays closer to home.
That means it can support not just one project, but the wider local economy around it, and new projects yet to emerge.
Figure 2: Financial flows through Make/Shift CPP – relational model
Of course, some spending will always leave the area; people travel, buy supplies, and use services that are (often unavoidably) non-local.
But even with those ‘leakages’, as our case study shows, hyperlocal funding can generate meaningful benefits, especially when money reaches local people, local suppliers, and local spaces.
This is one reason the study matters: it helps show that local funding is not just about fairness or accessibility, although those are important too. It is also about economic resilience; when resources are invested locally, more of the value can stay in the community and continue to support work there.
Trust is important
Make/Shift’s approach aimed to reduce barriers, simplify access, and give people more freedom to use funding in ways that felt right for their communities.
That matters because funding systems can often create pressure. If rules are too rigid, people may spend unnecessary time/effort/money trying to ‘fit the funding’, rather than on using it effectively.
By contrast, a more flexible approach can create space for creativity, confidence, and shared ownership.
Our case study suggested that this approach helped people feel recognised and valued at multiple levels;
- when people feel trusted to make decisions about who to fund, and why, or
- how to spend the money they’ve received from their peers
In both instances, they are more likely to contribute and collaborate generously.
“I believe that this kind of evaluation gives a more complete picture of value”
A virtuous circle in action
One of the clearest examples we encountered was Swanwick Men’s Shed.
A participant used a payment received through Make/Shift’s distributed decision-making structure: selected by local people, to support local communities.
A local panel member chose to use his fee to support the Men’s Shed, helping the group buy equipment and improve its presence at events. That investment then helped the group grow further, build confidence, and create their own new income opportunities.
Figure 3: Swanwick Men’s Shed financial and value flow model
This is an example of a ‘virtuous circle’. The original funding did not end with a single activity. Instead, it helped build capacity, skills, and future opportunity.
It is not only about the immediate output: where money is placed matters, and how it is distributed matters just as much.
Evaluating process, over product
Perhaps the most important question is not how money was used, so much as what it sets in motion.
This is especially important at a time when many organisations are under pressure to demonstrate impact quickly – as mentioned, some of the most meaningful outcomes take time and emerge through repeated relationships, shared learning, and the slow building of trust, confidence and capacity.
I feel strongly that funding (and its impact) is part of a living network of choices, relationships, and opportunities. It is not just an input, in the same way that evaluation is not just a report written at the end of a project.
Evaluation is also part of that living network, and (most importantly in the challenging environment facing the arts and creative sectors) must develop ways of reflecting the work it is a part of.
If you’d like to explore more of our evaluation of Make/Shift, the reports and case studies are available to download.
